Bob Higgins

A Legacy: The Eternal Nuclear Dump

Posted in Bob Higgins at Clean Technica, Environment, Nuclear Power, Politics by Bob Higgins on August 17, 2011


I got an email this morning inviting me to host a screening for a documentary film titled  “Into Eternity.” It’s the story of Onkalo which means hiding place or cave, a nuclear waste repository being constructed in Finland,  The film delves into the ethical questions of storing nuclear waste for centuries and the building of a facility to last 100,000 years when no structure that we know of has lasted a tenth that long.

I’ve been against the continued development of nuclear power and weapons since grade school when they used to send us to the basement to prepare for a Russian nuclear attack by crouching in the boiler room, covering our heads with our arms and kissing our little butts goodbye.

Originally posted at Clean Technica: A Legacy: The Eternal Nuclear Dump

Many of us from that generation lived with nightmares of mushroom clouds and the human silhouettes burned into Hiroshima’s sidewalks until we were in our teens.

The facility is the Onkalo nuclear waste repository and it’s currently being dug to a depth of some 1700 meters on the island of Olkiluoto, Finland. The idea here, like the ill fated project at Yucca Mountain, in Nevada is to create a long term solution for the disposal of high level nuclear waste.

The reactors at Olkiluoto are two Boiling Water Reactors, (think old, think Westinghouse and yes, think Fukushima)  Another unit is under construction, a (European Pressurized water Reactor) and suffering the problems of workmanship and design that arise when various parties begin disputing issues of responsibility and profit. It is suffering lengthy delays and cost overruns.  A fourth reactor is planned and has been licensed.

I’ve always been bothered by the term repository. I prefer the word dump. I think it’s a more honest and direct description of what’s being done. I find it difficult to think of something as evil as plutonium and other long term products of our nuclear follies laying in quiet repose deep in the earth for the 100,000 years they intend. I fear that when this stuff is finally unearthed it will still have a malignant smile on its face. Repose indeed, I think waiting for opportunity is more likely.

They estimate that the facility will hold about a hundred years worth of this toxic trash and then they will simply cover it up, seal the whole mess in the ground and walk away like a cat from his litter box daintily shaking his paws. Problem buried, case closed.

For tens of thousands of years we’ve been discarding our trash, old broken pottery, bent swords, dented helmets, ancient Roman spare-rib bones, every bit of the detritus of our societies, in dumps. We generally place them on the outskirts of town (NIMBY has been around for awhile) and build anew on top of them. I suspect that if we ever scrape away all the landfills we may find that the earth was originally no more impressive than the now demoted Pluto.

We remember our ancestors largely from what they have discarded in their trash dumps, some of which they may wish had been better hidden and we may share that wish.

A central theme of the film is, what will our descendents find and when will they find it? We believe that the most dangerous and long lived elements in the waste will be safe after 100,000 years or so. How can we keep some future Indiana Jones from digging it up and causing death and destruction in a future civilization? Have we the right to leave this dark bonus of a time capsule?

How can we warn them, what language might they understand, what symbols might we use to convey the message?

We are a civilization that ignores or glosses over its past mistakes, the horrors of its history and seems blissfully oblivious to all the terrible dangers that surround us in the present. With all the conflict and war, rapid population growth, dwindling supplies of resources, from water, to food, to energy, and the steadily warming temperature of the atmospheric stew we’re all simmering in, I’m amazed that anyone believes we will have descendents at all beyond a century or two.

But its nice to think that we’re more considerate of some future race of Elois or Morlocks and we take more care to protect them from harm than our present neighbors whom we are happy to simply slaughter wholesale.

Admittedly I haven’t seen the film, I’m just passing on what the producers told me by email, and what I saw on the impressive trailer but if you want to host a screening or help to promote this worthy film please go here.

It’s for a good cause.

Originally posted at Clean Technica: A Legacy: The Eternal Nuclear Dump
Photo: By kallerna (Own work) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Advertisements

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Jim Raleigh said, on August 17, 2011 at 10:32 am

    1) BWRs were made by General Electric, not Westinghouse, and in the US have additional safety enhancements over the BWRs at Fukushima.

    2) Considerable thought was put into the warnings and markers that were to be used at the Yucca Mountain Repository (YMR) to keep future inhabitants away from the nuclear waste (the designs can be found in the License Application for the YMR). Additionally, by the time a waste package underground at the YMR could be penetrated by a misguided driller looking for water or other resources the radiation of the waste would be approaching background levels (~300,000 years); which is also desribed in the YMR License Application.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: